[Salon] Yemen peace talks fail again



Yemen peace talks fail again

Summary: MbS is searching for a face-saving exit from the Yemen quagmire but the Houthis are determined to make him pay the full price for the war.

Fighting outside Marib and in Taiz has escalated since the beginning of the year, even as UN Envoy Hans Grundberg has engaged in extensive peace talks with all the parties in Yemen in order to try and end the war. So last week the Gulf Cooperation Council tried their hand at talks, inviting the warring Yemeni factions to Riyadh under its aegis, but the Houthis dismissed the offer out of hand. “Saudi Arabia is a party to the aggression and not a neutral party” said Houthi ‘ministry of foreign affairs’ spokesman Ahmed al-Imad. “There is nothing new. This is just an invitation for media consumption.”

Negotiations between the Houthis and the Saudis have in fact been going on behind closed doors for months, but the two sides are still far apart. The Saudi offer remains the same: an end to the war in exchange for payment of a to-be-agreed upon sum, while letting the Houthis keep the part of Yemen they currently control under some kind of yet to-be-decided federal arrangement.

In 2010, after Saudi Arabia had been drawn into war with the Houthis, they agreed a deal to end the conflict whereby the Saudis declared victory in exchange for a secret payment of tens of millions of dollars. MbS is hoping to repeat this sleight of hand again. But the Houthis were much weaker then than they are today. In 2010 they were ready to accept money and forgo a public victory. Now they want both, saying it is up to the Yemeni people to decide who controls which part of Yemen and MbS must pay $100 billion and issue a public apology.

Though it was predictable that the Houthis would refuse peace talks in Riyadh, it would have been highly desirable for MbS if they had gone ahead, because then whatever happened Saudi-controlled media could have found a way to spin it as the Houthis coming to him, begging to end the war.

It is absolutely vital to MBS that he does not lose face in front of the Saudi people, even when in fact it is he who is making most of the concessions.

That same principle applied when the US pressured MbS to end the Qatar feud. The crown prince did so by inviting the Qatari emir Sheikh Tamim to Riyadh, which Saudi media spun as a Saudi victory, even though in reality it was the Saudis who had to drop all their demands.

Data from @YemenData and @ACLEDINFO

In a double slap in the face to MbS, the Houthis’ refusal to attend the peace conference was followed up by a massive cross-border strike on Saudi Arabia and escalated attacks on government-controlled areas in Yemen.

The attacks inside the Kingdom caused no casualties but sparked a fire at Aramco’s North Jeddah Bulk Plant and disrupted production at a petrochemicals complex in Yanbu on the Red Sea coast. Satellite photos by Planet Labs PBC showed the attack struck the same oil storage tank in the North Jeddah Bulk Plant that the Houthis had previously hit in November 2020.

At a press conference afterwards the Saudi Energy Ministry acknowledged a temporary drop in oil output at the 400,000-barrel-a-day Yanbu site, without elaborating. The disruption “will be compensated for from the inventory," the ministry said, again without elaborating.

The Saudi Press Agency then issued a statement quoting the Saudi Foreign Ministry as saying that the kingdom “declares that it will not bear any responsibility for any shortage in oil supplies to global markets in light of the attacks on its oil facilities.” And it went on to say “the international community must assume its responsibility to preserve energy supplies,” in order to deter attacks that jeopardize “the kingdom’s production capability and its ability to fulfil its commitments.”

This was a remarkable demand for several reasons.

Firstly, when the Saudis launched their war against the Houthis in 2015 MbS claimed it would all be over in a matter of weeks; victory was just around the corner. Seven years of war later that claim has come back to haunt him. The kingdom and its essential energy sector are under attack and the crown prince who also serves as defence minister has shown himself incapable of protecting it. This foreign ministry statement effectively admits defeat.

Secondly, unlike the 2019 Abqaiq attack on Aramco which was on a different scale of magnitude affecting more than 30% of Saudi production, the Jeddah plant processes oil derivatives for domestic supply and so production and exports were unaffected. That enabled Saudi Aramco CEO Amin H. Nasser to tell reporters the attacks had no impact on oil supplies.

On the question of oil supplies, MbS could now, if he wished, open the pipe and immediately add 3.5 million barrels per day to the world quota which would go a long way to calm oil markets.

After the Abqaiq attack Saudi Arabia stressed it would speedily return to normal levels of production. There were no stark warnings about not taking responsibility for global oil supply shortages and no demands for “the international community to assume its responsibility.”  This time around, MbS is playing the deflection and blame game while looking for ways to escape mounting pressure from western governments to increase production.

Last week Boris Johnson visited Riyadh to tell the prince to his face and on behalf of both President Biden and himself that if he does not cooperate soon over energy policy there will be serious consequences for him. (For more on the visit see yesterday’s newsletter.)

Whether MbS will heed this warning remains to be seen. Jared Kushner and Donald Trump are encouraging the prince to stand firm in an attempt to destroy Biden’s upcoming election prospects, a strategy which already looks to be paying dividends as the US media turns to blaming Biden for the energy crisis.

On Tuesday the Saudi Cabinet issued a statement that the OPEC+ oil producers’ alliance plays an “essential role” in bringing balance and stability to oil markets but made no mention of increasing production.

According to the WSJ the Saudis’ next move could be selling some oil in Chinese yuan. Such a move has often been posited in the past, but this time it looks more likely, in a limited form at least, as it would be another way for MbS to embarrass Biden.

The fact this story appeared in the WSJ however means it should be treated with a degree of caution. Like Axios, the WSJ has recently published false information about Saudi Arabia including the widely quoted article about MbS refusing to take a call from Biden. What actually happened is President Biden called King Salman and the Royal Court told him the king could not take his call, but he could speak to the crown prince instead. Biden refused. The WSJ story, which the White House said was inaccurate after it was published, presented the exact reverse.


Members can leave comments about this newsletter on the Today's Newsletter page of the Arab Digest website
follow us on TwitterLinkedIn and Facebook

Copyright © 2022 Arab Digest, All rights reserved.
You are receiving this email as you are subscribed to the Arab Digest.
Our mailing address is:
Arab Digest
3rd Floor
207 Regent Street
London, W1B 3HH
United Kingdom



 To unsubscribe from this list log in to ArabDigest.org


This archive was generated by a fusion of Pipermail (Mailman edition) and MHonArc.